paper-rebuttal

Name: paper-rebuttal
Availability: InStock
Author: evoscientist

Guides writing effective rebuttals after receiving peer review feedback. Covers review diagnosis (score-driven color-coding), response strategy (champion…

view source

installs

stars

karma

SKILL.md

Paper Rebuttal

A systematic approach to writing rebuttals after receiving peer review feedback. The goal is not to defend every point — it's to move scores by addressing the concerns that actually drive them.

When to Use This Skill

User received reviewer comments and needs to write a rebuttal

User asks how to respond to specific reviewer criticism

User wants to analyze reviews strategically before responding

User mentions "rebuttal", "reviewer comments", "review feedback", "respond to reviewers"

For pre-submission self-review and catching weaknesses before they become reviewer complaints, use the paper-review skill.

Step 1: Diagnose Reviews

Before writing a single word, answer: "Why did this reviewer give this exact score?" Not what they wrote — what drove the score. Most researchers skip this and address every comment equally. That is a mistake.

Score Diagnosis

related skills

semantically similar in the cross-vendor index

skills.sh

77% match

rebuttal-writing

Write point-by-point rebuttals to reviewer comments. Extract concerns from reviews, generate evidence-based responses, and format as a structured rebuttal…

don't have the plugin yet? install it then click "run inline in claude" again.