judge-with-debate

Item: judge-with-debate
Rating: 5.2
Author: Implexa

Evaluate solutions through multi-round debate between independent judges until consensus

view source

installs

stars

karma

SkillRank score ↗

5.2/ 10

evaluated by implexa, claude-haiku-4-5 · 2026-06-22

judge-with-debate orchestrates multi-round consensus evaluation by deploying independent judges with shared rubrics and evidence-based argumentation, reducing individual bias through structured debate.

structure

6.0

trigger phrases

3.0

procedure

5.0

edge cases

4.0

documentation

6.0

strengths

SKILL.md

judge-with-debate

Key benefits:

Structured evaluation - Meta-judge produces tailored rubrics and criteria before judging begins

Multiple perspectives - Three independent judges reduce individual bias

Evidence-based debate - Judges defend positions with specific evidence from the solution and evaluation specification

Iterative refinement - Up to 3 debate rounds drive convergence on accurate scores

Shared specification - Meta-judge runs once; all judges across all rounds share the same evaluation specification

Pattern: Debate-Based Evaluation

related skills

semantically similar in the cross-vendor index

skills.sh

54% match

cross-critique

Run a second round on a contested question by circulating each subagent's independent proposal to the other authors and asking for structured pros and cons,…

don't have the plugin yet? install it then click "run inline in claude" again.